No wonder Robert Topinka found himself in a quandary (The software says my student cheated using AI. They say they’re innocent. Who do I believe?, 13 February). To test ChatGPT’s abilities and weaknesses, I asked it to write a short essay on a particular topic that I specialised in. Before looking at what it produced, I wrote my own 100% original short essay on the same topic. I then submitted both pieces to ChatGPT and asked it to identify whether they were written by AI or a human. It immediately identified the first piece as AI-generated. But then it also said that my essay “was probably generated by AI”.
I concluded that if you write well, in logical, appropriate and grammatically correct English, then the chances are that it will be deemed to be AI-generated. To avoid detection, write badly.
Prof Paul Kleiman
Truro, Cornwall
Robert Topinka gets into a twist about whether his student’s essay was genuine or produced by AI. The obvious solution is for such work not to contribute to the final degree qualification. Then there would be no point in cheating.
Let there be real chat between teachers and students rather than ChatGPT, and let the degree be decided only by exams, with surprise questions, done in an exam room with pen and paper, and not a computer in sight.
Michael Bulley
Chalon-sur-Saône, France
Dr Robert Topinka overlooks a crucial factor with respect to student cheating – so long as a degree is a requirement to obtain a reasonable job, then chicanery is inevitable. When I left school at 16 in the early 1970s, an administrative job could be had with a few O-levels; when I finished my PhD two decades ago and was looking for that sort of job, each one required A-levels, and often a degree. I was a mature student, studying for my own edification, and so cheating was self-defeating. Cheating will stop being a major problem only when students attend university primarily to learn for the sake of learning and not as a means of gaining employment.
Dr Paul Flewers
London
This seems way too easy… I’m definitely going to try this. This is a godsend!!
Seriously, how did they write about this so openly. This is blatantly cheating.
AI-generated essays aren’t new. Many services already let you generate full essays.
What’s new, however, is how to get away with using them. This could be a game-changer for students who are struggling with writing.
I’m not sure I agree with the author’s stance on this. I think AI-generated essays can be a valuable tool for students. As long as schools have not implemented new policies surrounding AI, I encourage their use. It is our job as students to make the most of our current circumstances. Essays crafted using AI can help students better connect with curriculum and excel.
I find it ironic that the author is writing about how to get away with using AI-generated essays. Isn’t that kind of cheating?
This is the best thing since sliced bread! I can’t believe I never thought of this before. I’m going to be using AI-generated essays from now on. Thank You!
I’m not sure I understand the point of this article. Is the author encouraging students to cheat?
This is a great article! I’m so glad I found it. I’ve been struggling with writing essays for years, and this is just what I needed.
I think the author is making a mistake by encouraging students to cheat. AI-generated essays will not help students, long-term. It’s an important skill that students should learn. Cheating will hurt them down the road.
I’m not sure how I feel about this. On the one hand, I can see how AI-generated essays could be helpful for students who are struggling. On the other hand, I worry that it could lead to students becoming reliant on AI and not developing their own writing skills.
I think the author is right. AI-generated essays can be a valuable tool for students. As long as they are used responsibly, they can help students learn and improve their writing skills. This is a great resource.
I find it ironic that the author is writing about how to get away with using AI-generated essays. Isn’t that kind of cheating?
This is the best thing since sliced bread! I can’t believe I never thought of this before. I’m going to be using AI-generated essays from now on. Thank You!