How human are chatbots? Do they really know what we are thinking, and should we fear them?
That’s what Rob and Neil are talking about, and they teach you some useful vocabulary along the way.
The first computer program that allowed some kind of plausible conversation between humans and machines was invented in 1966, but what was it called?
a) ALEXA
b) ELIZA
c) PARRY
sophisticated
describes technology that is more advanced and complex
coherent
clear, carefully considered and sensible
authoritative
respected, accurate and important sounding
on guard
careful and alert
provoke
do something that causes a reaction from someone
sentient
living thing that experiences feelings
Note: This is not a word-for-word transcript.
Neil
Hello. This is 6 Minute English from BBC Learning English. I’m Neil.
Rob
And I’m Rob.
Neil
Now, I’m sure most of us have interacted with a chatbot. These are bits of computer technology that respond to text with text or respond to your voice. You ask it a question and it usually comes up with an answer!
Rob
Yes, it’s almost like talking to another human, but of course it’s not – it’s just a clever piece of technology. It is becoming more sophisticated – more advanced and complex, but could they replace real human interaction altogether?
Neil
We’ll discuss that more in a moment and find out if chatbots really think for themselves. But first I have a question for you, Rob. The first computer program that allowed some kind of plausible conversation between humans and machines was invented in 1966, but what was it called? Was it:
a) ALEXA
b) ELIZA
c) PARRY
Rob
It’s not Alexa – that’s too new – so I’ll guess c) PARRY.
Neil
I’ll reveal the answer at the end of the programme. Now, the old chatbots of the 1960s and 70s were quite basic, but more recently, the technology is able to predict the next word that is likely to be used in a sentence, and it learns words and sentence structures.
Rob
It’s clever stuff. I’ve experienced using them when talking to my bank – or when I have problems trying to book a ticket on a website. I no longer phone a human but I speak to a ‘virtual assistant’ instead. Probably the most well-known chatbot at the moment is ChatGTP.
Neil
It is. The claim is it’s able to answer anything you ask it. This includes writing students’ essays. This is something that was discussed on the BBC Radio 4 programme, Word of Mouth. Emily M Bender, Professor of Computational Linguistics at the University of Washington, explained why it’s dangerous to always trust what a chatbot is telling us…
Emily M Bender, Professor of Computational Linguistics at the University of Washington
We tend to react to grammatical fluent coherent seeming text as authoritative and reliable and valuable – and we need to be on guard against that, because what’s coming out of ChatGTP is none of that.
Rob
So, Professor Bender says that well written text that is coherent – that means it’s clear, carefully considered and sensible – makes us think what we are reading is reliable and authoritative. So it is respected, accurate and important sounding.
Neil
Yes, chatbots might appear to write in this way, but really, they are just predicting one word after another, based on what they have learnt. We should, therefore, be on guard – be careful and alert about the accuracy of what we are being told.
Rob
One concern is that chatbots – a form of artificial intelligence – work a bit like a human brain in the way it can learn and process information. They are able to learn from experience – something called deep learning.
Neil
A cognitive psychologist and computer scientist called Geoffrey Hinton, recently said he feared that chatbots could soon overtake the level of information that a human brain holds. That’s a bit scary isn’t it?
Rob
For now, chatbots can be useful for practical information, but sometimes we start to believe they are human, and we interact with them in a human-like way. This can make us believe them even more. Professor Emma Bender, speaking on the BBC’s Word of Mouth programme, explains why we meet feel like that…
Emily M Bender, Professor of Computational Linguistics at the University of Washington
I think what’s going on there is the kinds of answers you get depend on the questions you put in, because it’s doing likely next word, likely next word, and so if as the human interacting with the machine you start asking it questions about ‘how do you feel, you know, Chatbot?’ ‘What do you think of this?’ And. ‘what are your goals?’ You can provoke it to say things that sound like what a sentient entity would say… We are really primed to imagine a mind behind language whenever we encounter language. And so, we really have to account for that when we’re making decisions about these.
Neil
So, although a chatbot might sound human, we really just ask it things to get a reaction – we provoke it – and it answers only with words it’s learned to use before, not because it has come up with a clever answer. But it does sound like a sentient entity – sentient describes a living thing that experiences feelings.
Rob
As Professor Bender says, we imagine that when something speaks there is a mind behind it. But sorry, Neil, they are not your friend, they are just machines!
Neil
It’s strange then that we sometimes give chatbots names. Alexa, Siri… and earlier I asked you what the name was for the first ever chatbot.
Rob
And I guessed it was PARRY. Was I right?
Neil
You guessed wrong, I’m afraid. PARRY was an early form of chatbot from 1972, but the correct answer was ELIZA. It was considered to be the first ‘chatterbot’ – as it was called then, and was developed by Joseph Weizenbaum at Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Rob
Fascinating stuff. OK, now let’s recap some of the vocabulary we highlighted in this programme. Starting with sophisticated which can describe technology that is advanced and complex.
Neil
Something that is coherent is clear, carefully considered and sensible.
Rob
Authoritative – so it is respected, accurate and important sounding.
Neil
When you are on guard you must be careful and alert about something – it could be accuracy of what you see or hear, or just being aware of the dangers around you.
Rob
To provoke means to do something that causes a reaction from someone.
Neil
Sentient describes something that experiences feelings – so it’s something that is living. Once again, our six minutes are up. Goodbye.
Rob
Bye for now.
How can female farmers beat rural sexism?
What can the Moon tell us about Earth?
Do we even want to live without plastic?
Could we eat invasive species?
Mozzarella, ricotta, cannolis and focaccia… Where are we? Little Italy of course!
What are the health risks of social media for teenagers?
Have you ever seen an alien?
How can you stop elephants eating your crops?
Is it OK to eat animals that can feel emotion?
How do people live to 100?
Do you know how your money is being invested?
Should we be using mushrooms as medicine?
How can dead languages be revived?
Are there any sounds you find upsetting?
What language do fans use?
Do men find it hard to make and keep friends?
How can we find space for more solar panels?
What do our names reveal about our culture and family history?
Can we adapt to heatwaves?
Does work leave you feeling bored and exhausted?
What is eco-anxiety and do you have it?
Can natural disasters be prevented?
Different ways to say sorry.
Do you pick the fruit you eat from trees?
Can plants clean up our mess?
How human are chatbots?
Should we treat plants with the same consideration we treat animals with?
Does sound make food taste better?
Would being lazy have a purpose in life?
Hear how subtitles can help bring TV and movies to life
We discuss the growing popularity of ecotourism.
With warming temperatures, mosquitos are now spreading to new areas, including Europe.
Listen to an expert on the global food system.
BBC war correspondent Fergal Keane tells his story.
We talk about an essential element for life to thrive.
We discuss some of the reasons why women make up only 26% of the world’s politicians.
We discuss the role of museums in the 21st century and the items taken from different countries.
What ways do you think culture can influence sadness?
Hear about a new kind of vegetable making an entrance in British kitchens
Let’s talk about the ugly green-eyed monster
We discuss the role of crowds in modern life
We look at the link between what you eat and how you feel.
The dos and don’ts of trying to discuss science with someone who doesn’t believe in it
Hear the story of a woman who replaced her native Czech for English.
Could ‘an apple a day keep the doctor away’?
Do you leave your work until the last minute?
What is doomscrolling and why are we attracted to bad news? Listen to find out!
What’s the least amount of exercise you should do to stay healthy?
Hear about the software engineer who became ‘friends’ with his computer
Does the size of your carbon footprint depend on where in the world you were born? Listen to find out!
Neil and Sam discuss buffet meals and the history behind them.
Writing a memorable song isn’t easy. So is there an art to good songwriting?
For a better experience please enable Javascript in your browser
