Israel has continued insisting there isn’t a huge need for more aid in Gaza – enough is getting in, say its officials, with more food than before the war, they’ve even claimed.
It’s all the UN’s fault for not distributing it properly, they add.
Well, President Joe Biden‘s stunning Gaza port announcement is clearly a sign that the US is not buying any of that.
This is the American government saying it’s going to have to send its military potentially into harm’s way to make up for the failure of its own ally.
The Israelis have said they welcome the decision and will fully cooperate with it.
And apart from the fact it shows up some glaring shortcomings in its handling of the war, this is good news for Israel. The aid will all be screened in Cyprus – so there’s no worry about weapons being smuggled in.
It relieves Israel of its responsibilities to meet the humanitarian needs of the civilian population whose land they are occupying.
And it draws America into this war – which means when it’s over maybe the US will take more of a role in Gaza -something the Israelis would love to see.
But there are so many questions.
What other mission creep will this lead to?
How will the Americans guarantee their own safety? There are plenty of groups supported by Iran in Gaza who would love to strike a blow at US forces and cover themselves in Islamist glory.
Analysis from the US:
Biden’s decision shows his desperation
Or what happens if a stray Hamas rocket or Israeli missile hits a group of US engineers and kills a few in an election year? The jeopardy for Joe Biden is obvious.
And why is this necessary?
The Erez crossing on Gaza’s northern border lies idle.
It could be opened tomorrow to allow aid to be funnelled in and landed from the Israeli ports of Ashdod and Ashkelon, also from Cyprus. That would be a lot safer and easier to pull off.
Read more:
US to build Gaza port as Palestinians starve – war latest
Is famine about to be declared in Gaza?
Israel completes construction of road which cuts across Gaza Strip
The decision seems desperate and ill thought through.
It is without doubt quite a gamble for the American president who will be running against a man who sees votes in American isolation and withdrawal from foreign places.
Then, of course, the tragically obvious point – Americans are good at building military infrastructure but not quickly.
It will take weeks and the poor starving people of Gaza cannot wait that long.
Yeah, I'm sure Biden has a brilliant plan for Gaza. He's such a great strategist. I mean, look at how well he's handled the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I'm curious to see how Biden's Gaza port gamble plays out. I'm not sure if it's a good idea or not, but I'm interested to see what happens.
Oh, Biden is such a great president. He's really doing a bang-up job of keeping us safe and out of war.
Biden's Gaza port gamble is like a bad joke. It's not funny, and it's going to end badly.
The Gaza Strip is a narrow coastal enclave between Israel and Egypt. It's home to about 2 million Palestinians, most of whom are refugees from the 1948 Arab-Israeli war.
The Gaza Strip has been under Israeli blockade since 2007. The blockade has crippled the economy and caused a humanitarian crisis.
I don't think Biden's Gaza port gamble is ill thought through at all. I think it's a necessary step to help improve the lives of the Palestinian people.
I'm really worried about the potential consequences of Biden's Gaza port gamble. I hope he knows what he's doing.
Biden's Gaza port gamble seems like a reckless move that could have disastrous consequences. I'm really worried that this could lead to war and put Americans in harm's way.
I think Biden's Gaza port gamble is a risky move, but I understand why he's doing it. I just hope he has a plan for what happens if things go wrong.
I think Biden's Gaza port gamble is a reckless move that could have disastrous consequences. I'm really worried about the potential for escalation.
I think you should take into account that it's incorrect to jump to conclusions and say that Biden's Gaza port gamble is ill thought through and risks drawing the US into war. We should wait for more information before making such a strong statement.
I'm cynical about Biden's Gaza port gamble. I don't think it's going to work, and I'm worried about the potential consequences.
I think it's too early to say whether Biden's Gaza port gamble is ill thought through or not. We need to wait and see how it plays out.
I'm really passionate about this issue. I think Biden's Gaza port gamble is a great idea. I hope it succeeds.